Taff Trail Hailey Park – Update May 2024

IMG_9363 2

We have read Cardiff Council’s Consultation Report into the proposed changes to the Taff Trail cycle path in Hailey Park, Cardiff, published on 9th May 2024.

To recap, the council’s proposal consists of two phases:

  1. Widening of the existing path running west to east along the route of the river, but with a diversion to avoid the protected Wax Cap Grassland to the west of the Tennis courts. The diverted section runs parallel with Mary Street and then turns south to rejoin the existing path near to the Llandaf Bridge underpass.
  2. Construction of a new cycleway from the Ty Mawr Road gate, running south below the area of woodland next to the Radyr Road car park, linking up with the existing Taff Trail path at the bottom of the park next to the river.

Missed opportunity

We’re disappointed that the council have decided to press ahead with their original proposal, albeit with some minor changes and very little meaningful public consultation with key stakeholders. We had hoped that Cardiff Council would see this project as an opportunity to be truly bold in implementing an ambitious but transformative piece of Active Travel infrastructure.

Lack of proportionate investment

We understand the financial environment that Cardiff Council and Welsh Government are operating under. However, Welsh Government has already found over £4million to invest in the Roath Park cycleway project this year, compared to just £713,000 for the Hailey Park Taff Trail scheme. It is disappointing that the Taff Trail is only deemed worthy of less than a quarter of the investment which is being made in Roath Park, resulting in a project which does not deliver any significant improvement in its current form – a waste of public money. The Taff Trail is the busiest commuter and leisure cycling route in the city and it deserves the same level of investment as Roath Park, if not more.

Increasing conflict

C=CC does not believe that the current proposal will reduce conflict between pedestrians and cyclists in the park. In fact, it is likely to increase conflict due to the disruption caused during construction and also because the council have seen fit to persist in using shared paths. The reason given in the council’s report is,

… a fully segregated facility is unlikely to keep pedestrians and cyclists completely separate at all times.

This may be true, but a segregated facility will always be a better way of keeping pedestrians and cyclists safe compared to a shared one.

As we pointed out in our previous response:

Shared-use paths are not good Active Travel infrastructure and should never be the choice in a multi-user environment like Hailey Park where high volumes of active travel traffic are encountered. There should be separate, dedicated routes so that the potential for pedestrian and cyclist conflict is minimised.

Most of the council’s solutions to mitigating conflict involve the deployment of signage; there is no evidence that signage in other parkland areas in the city has had any effect in reducing conflict between users of shared paths.

The land that is now Hailey Park was gifted to the local community by Claude Hailey in 1923. Recently the park’s green spaces have been compromised by the construction of a controversial sewage pumping station. The council’s Taff Trail proposals will further undermine the park’s status as an unspoilt green space.

We are not aware of any stakeholders who have made a positive submission regarding the proposed scheme. Does the council have any such submissions they can share?

Lack of consistency

The current proposal includes design elements where the new cycleway will pass underneath large mature trees. We noted in our previous response that these trees would require maintenance to reduce overhang and tree debris on the cycleway. The council does not seem to think this will be an issue, but we note that one reason the council has rejected C=CC’s proposal to use the old canal bed route is because of “low tree canopies and root protection areas.” Why are these different?

We should also point out that there is just one domestic garage on the canal bed lane to the north of the park. Parking and access for residents (if there really is any reasonable demand for this, which we doubt) could easily be maintained with sympathetic design. It is alarming that the council have chosen to prioritise the perceived needs of a very small number of motorists at the expense of other users of the park. 

The council has declared a climate emergency. With this comes a responsibility to encourage people to walk and cycle instead of driving. It certainly doesn’t mean that the council should be making allowances for motorists so they can continue to drive and park their vehicles in a public park. 

Speed

There is a lot of concern about the speed of some cyclists who travel through the park. Whilst signage is welcome, it is not an effective solution to this problem. We all know that segregated cycling infrastructure is the only effective solution which ensures cyclists and pedestrians can move safely at their own speeds. Our proposal put forward a separate, segregated cycle path which would have achieved this aim. Instead, the council seems determined to press ahead with a route which passes directly next to the children’s playground.

The council’s proposal includes a diverted route to the north of the tennis courts, to avoid the area where wax cap fungi are present. We noted that this route does not follow the desire line, but it also introduces a gradient which may deter less confident or disabled cyclists. It also follows that cyclists’ speeds may increase as they descend the gradient, introducing a risk of collision.

Future Generations Responsibilities

The council has missed a golden opportunity to tackle the problem of traffic volumes and problem parking around Ysgol Glantaf. We recommended that the council implement a “School Street” on Gabalfa Road, providing a safe route for school children on bicycles as well as cycle commuters. This would reduce “school run” motor traffic and make the area around the school safer and more attractive for everyone. 

In addition, a direct entrance to Ysgol Glantaf via the Taff Trail would be a truly transformative initiative which would enable children to access the school on foot and by bicycle safely and conveniently. It would also significantly reduce motor vehicle (“school run”) traffic around the school. This is the very least the council could do, if they continue to refuse to look at converting Gabalfa Road into a School Street.

The number of pupils cycling to school at Glantaf continues to grow, but because the approaches to the school are dominated by motor vehicles, there have been numerous incidents in recent years. These incidents will continue until the problems of traffic congestion and dangerous parking are addressed. Safe cycling infrastructure, as proposed by C=CC in our previous response, would go a long way to fixing these problems.

It appears that the council has given very little consideration to our proposals in this area, mostly on the grounds that they will cost more than the council’s scheme. We would be interested to know how much work has been done to determine the cost of implementing our school street proposal.

Finally, we must again draw attention to the £4million Roath Park scheme where it seems that when the council is committed to providing effective active travel infrastructure, it is able to secure the funding to do so.

Waste of money

In our previous response we also noted:

  • Where the path is close to the river, the surface is collapsing due to frequent flooding and will eventually prove impossible to maintain
  • The riverside leg south-[east] beyond Hailey Park (to the [south] of Glantaf school) has already flooded in recent years. Global warming will no doubt see an increase in the frequency of dangerous submersion of this leg.
  • The underpass under Llandaf Bridge can be hazardous where the pedestrian steps descend onto the path, with no visibility
  • The bends in the path by Llandaf Weir are also hazardous as the sightlines are poor
  • Some sections are also compromised by root damage from trees, which makes them uncomfortable or hazardous to ride

It was therefore concerning to see that the council has plans in 2025 to widen this section of the Taff Trail which runs to the south of Glantaf School, next to the river. In our view this would be a total waste of money for the reasons listed above.

Better to do nothing

In summary, the proposed scheme DOES NOT:

  • Encourage modal shift
  • Reduce conflict between cyclists and other park users
  • Preserve green spaces
  • Make the cycling journey through the park safer and quicker for anyone
  • Protect the route against future risks such as flooding and erosion

Furthermore, we are not aware of any stakeholders who are in favour of the council’s current proposal. It benefits no-one in its current form, and on that basis it would be better to do nothing at all than spend over £700,000 on a flawed scheme that nobody wants.

We strongly urge the council to reconsider their plans.

You can read all about the background to this issue on our information page, here:

2 thoughts on “Taff Trail Hailey Park – Update May 2024”

  1. I’m incredibly disappointed by C=CC lack of consideration to the residents of Hazelhurst Road, and the direct impact your proposal has on them. The ‘canal bed’ you refer to dose not exist – the canal was replaced with the lime trees by the council many years ago. The road you are referring to is for the residents of Hazelhurst Road to access their properties, as our deeds dictate in the form of a easement. Your proposal impeds this access, which is a breach of the easement that serves all residents who’s properties are accessed via this rear lane.

    I’d like to thank you for pointing out there is ‘just one’ domestic garage (there are two), however there are 4 properties with vehicle access to their properties, via this lane. You have “doubted” there is “reasonable demand” for vehicle access, however this assumption is wildly incorrect. Not only do the 47 families of Hazelhurst Road frequently use this lane to access and park vehicles at the rear of their properties (as they have a right to do so), deliveries vehicles (including 8 tonne trucks) and building contractors also frequently use the lane to access the properties. Not to mention the council maintenance vehicles that regularly use the narrow lane to maintain the park land, the local rugby and football teams, as well as emergency vehicles.

    I am very intrigued to see what ‘sympathetic design’ would allow a cyclist to safely pass vehicles down the narrow lane, when anything larger than a small car completely obstructs the lane.

    I also note your concern of the close proximity of the proposed plans to the children’s play park, however I am of a much greater concern of the 47 residents who’s rear property would step DIRECTLY onto your proposed cycle path. Particularly of the elderly, young children and dogs who would be stepping from their properties with limited visibility directly into the path of cyclists travelling at high speeds. What considering do you have for these residents and cyclists?

    The lane is marginally wider than the existing path, and is as equally busy as the original path that is being resigned to prevent accidents. 100s (no exaggeration) of walkers use this lane every day, as it is a main access path that many residents of Llandaff North use to access Hailey’s Park, as well as a circuit route that many dog walkers use. How does your proposal improve the existing issues, by moving the problem to another multi use path (that is also frequently used by vehicles!) that would be impossible to ever widen.

    I’m incredibly grateful that Cardiff council “have chosen to prioritise the perceived needs of a very small number of motorists”. The needs are not ‘perceived’. They are needed, frequently used, and a right of access of the landowners.

    Your lack of knowledge of the local community, lack of consideration for residents, and ignorance of the easement your proposal impeds means that I am in full support of the council’s plans.

    1. I’ve been using Hailey Park for 50 years – there is plenty of scope for widening the path which runs along the top of the park whilst maintaining segregated access for pedestrians and also access for motorists who have the right to use the existing lane. Our proposal does not affect residents’ rights under the easement, but I would point out that the lane is an adopted highway, which means it’s a public right of way which the council have a duty to maintain. Our proposal presents an opportunity for the council to improve the right of way by making it safe and accessible for everyone who needs to use it, whether they’re pedestrians, cyclists or motorists.

Comments are closed.