Supermarket sweep
Lots of us endeavour to bake cycling into our everyday lives. And why wouldn’t you? The more we replace short car journeys with cycling the more our beloved capital city benefits from reduced congestion, fewer road casualties, better air quality, less noise pollution, smaller contribution to climate change, improved transport equality and more liveable spaces. Plus, we as individuals enjoy improved physical and mental health from an activity that’s inherently fun.
But, to achieve this shift in transport habits the practicalities need to work. With that in mind we recently asked our Cardiff Cycle City members and followers to help us to survey the good, the bad and the ugly of supermarket cycle storage. Whether you’re popping in for a pint of milk, or doing the weekly family food shop with your cargo bike, you need to be confident that your two-wheeled steed will still be safely locked up outside when you’re done. Cycle theft, both the reality and the perceived fear, are barriers to everyday cycling.
That’s why we’re shining a light on supermarkets and their provision for securely locking bicycles, tricycles and cargo bikes is important. The survey results are in. It’s time to praise the best and shame the worst! Read on…

Talking shop
To underpin this campaign our lovely Cardiff Cycle City members and followers travelled to the four corners of Cardiff, and even a little beyond, in their quest to assess the state of supermarket cycle storage. The online survey we provided captured their findings on the provision (or not) of cycle locking facilities, how many regular bicycles could be accommodated, what space exists for cargo bikes or trikes, whether the racks were under cover and conveniently located, whether they were well maintained and litter (and motorbike) free and whether they were well-lit and visible. We also gathered general free-form feedback which at times proved enlightening!
At this stage, we only surveyed supermarkets that have their own customer car park; smaller kerbside retailers arguably have less control over the provision of storage. We may come back to those another time!
All over the shop
Our members and followers didn’t disappoint! Completed surveys poured in, spanning ALDI, ASDA, Co-op, LIDL, M&S Food, Morrisons, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and Waitrose outlets. Geographically we achieved coverage across Cardiff city centre, Bay and suburbs, Taff’s Well, Penarth and even Cowbridge.

Sweet shop
Our findings shed real light on the storage needs of cycling shoppers.
In a far-away cycling utopia perhaps covered, hinged cycle hangars would prove the exemplar. There are complexities around access and larger bikes like cargo bikes, but for the supermarket brand willing to rise to such a gold standard imagine the brand loyalty that might instill in cyclists. Plot spoiler: No supermarket in or around Cardiff reached this pinnacle.
Back in the real World, our survey responses suggested a storage sweet spot something along these lines:
- Plentiful bike stands, in sufficient number that they’re never all full, that allow frame (not just wheel) locking
- Securely ground or wall anchored (not pulling out of broken up concrete or slabs)
- Capable of accommodating larger cargo bikes, trikes and trailers
- Covered (from the rain)
- Conveniently located near the store entrance
- Visible, from the store and surroundings, with plenty of nearby footfall
- Well-lit
- Well maintained (not full of litter or used packaging and serving as a smoking area)
- Overlooked by store security staff and/or CCTV
Top shop
Before we open the awards-style envelope for the winning supermarket brand, here are the mid-tier also-rans: ASDA, LIDL, M&S Food, Morrisons, Tesco and Waitrose all surveyed as having “no-frills essentials” rather than the “best, exceptional finest” cycle storage provision!

Above these middling brands, on the second step of the cycle storage podium, came Sainsbury’s.
That leaves our top shop for supermarket cycle storage provision: ALDI. All the ALDI branches surveyed scored fairly well. The most-liked ALDI branch was on Caerphilly Road in Birchgrove. Here our survey respondents liked the locking facilities right outside the huge glass storefront overlooked from the tills and isles inside the store and the busy Caerphilly Road outside. There were widely spaced hoops with some space for bigger (e.g. cargo) bikes. The area is covered, and users don’t have to share space with cars in the car park to get to the locks. Sadly the CCTV inside the store by the adjacent tills doesn’t extend to the cycle locks (we asked). And it’s not our covered, hinged cycle hangar utopia. However, our respondents still judged it the best storage provision surveyed in Cardiff. Chapeau ALDI!
Junk shop
So, lastly, who were the villains of the piece? Firstly, three (dis)honourable mentions in the spillage-in-isle end of our supermarket branches:
Although LIDL branches overall came out mid-table, the large store on Cowbridge Road West brought survey scorn upon itself by removing racks near the entrance to install a parcel collection point, with no dedicated replacement. “Big on quality, LIDL on…” active travel?
Not far away, on Cowbridge Road East, Tesco has car parking but no cycle provision whatsoever. “Every little helps” active travel, Tesco!
Also, we feel compelled to mention that, despite being middling overall as a brand, Tesco’s Excelsior Road (Western Avenue) store attracted a litany of negative comments in our survey; from loose bolted stands to respondents who reported having a bike stolen from there in broad daylight. The security guard(s) there did at least attract positive comments, but it’s clear from our respondents that they’re often nervous about using the facilities there, and some avoid them altogether.
So, it only remains to name and shame the very worst performing supermarket brand in our survey. Take a bow, or bow your heads, Co-op. Our survey respondents disliked the entire lack of cycling provision at the Cowbridge Road East (again!) branch, despite the car parking provision. At Co-op’s Taff’s Well branch things were only marginally better: Storage at the previous Taff’s Well store wasn’t ever so good, but at least it was near the entrance over overlooked from the pavement and road and mounted solidly to the front supermarket wall. When the replacement Co-op store opened a couple of years ago things deteriorated further. We’re now offered a handful of extremely cramped insecure wheel (not frame) attachment type locks that are mounted on a not-overly-robust looking wooden fence. They’re located in a gloomy corner of the car park, away from the entrance, not overlooked, with the only footfall being members of Co-op staff tending the cages of rubbish that the locks share space with. “Owned by you. Right by…” motorists only, Co-op”?
9 items or less
So, there you have it. Our survey points at a 9 item cycle storage wish-list that every supermarket should deliver if it wants to attract and retain the custom of cyclists in and around Cardiff. We’ve also derived the specially-selected-stuffed-turkey-crown of supermarkets, through to the bargain-bucket-turkey-twizzlers when it comes to safe and convenient cycle storage.
To any supermarkets out there, please do get in touch if you want to see feedback specific to your brand. We’ll happily share this in the hope it’ll drive improvements.
Finally, a huge Cardiff Cycle City “thank you” to all our many survey respondents, and to C=CC member Ellen who ran enthusiastically with this initiative behind the scenes. If you have an idea for a cycle-themed campaign in and around Cardiff, let us know…
