BREAKING NEWS! Illegal Ely Trail Barriers Replaced!

Ely Grangemoor new 2

ANOTHER VICTORY FOR CARDIFF CYCLE CITY’S CAMPAIGNERS

NEWSFLASH! We’re very pleased to announce that the illegal barriers in Grangemoor Park have been removed and replaced with accessible entrances to the park. This will allow everyone to use the park, whether on a two-wheeled cycle or adapted trike or cargo bike. This is another big win for Cardiff Cycle City’s campaigning work to make our city the best in the UK for cycling!

New accessible barriers at the Penarth Road entrance to the park

You can read more about the background to this issue by following the links at the end of this article. Since this update was published we have received a statement from Cardiff Council which is quoted in full below.

On the western side of Cardiff, the Ely Trail is a circa 7 mile largely traffic-free walking and cycling route. It winds its way from Cardiff Bay and Penarth at the coast to St Fagans north west of the city.

The trail is just a short hop from Cardiff Bay, Penarth, Llandough, Leckwith, Caerau, Victoria Park, Canton, Riverside, Ely, Pentrebane, St Fagans or Michaelston-super-Ely. Its route largely follows the River Ely and should provide easy access to the river, open countryside, wildlife, St Fagans National History Museum and all these neighbourhoods. But there’s a problem: Barriers.

“A-gate” barriers on the Ely Trail – now thankfully gone !

Of the three main entrances (Ferry Road, Penarth Road and Dunleavy Drive) to the Ely Trail in the Grangemoor Park area, motorbikes and illegal e-bikes are likely to be able to enter/exit at all three, whereas law-abiding legitimate users with cargo bikes, bike trailers, tandem bikes, tricycles, wheelchairs, pushchairs (etc) may well be restricted to a single entrance/exit with no through route.

This renders it ineffective as an active travel route, perpetuates anti-social behaviour, and contravenes the Equality Act 2010.

It has now been over 3 years since we first highlighted this issue to Cardiff Council. We’ve had numerous discussions with local councillors, cabinet members and council officers, along with local stakeholders with an interest in accessible Active Travel – Pedal Power. There was even an academic study commissioned, which looked at Grangemoor Park and the effect of these barriers, and their subsequent removal, on Active Travel.

The first phase of the study, with the barriers in place, completed in the Spring. However, we’ve yet to see the results.

When the study was commissioned back in 2024, the council’s plan was to remove the illegal barriers, replacing them with accessible entrances. The study would then be repeated in a second phase, to measure the effect on levels and type of use of the Ely Trail in the park.

But it appears that the council have backtracked on this plan. In fact, we are told that the Parks Department, led by Cabinet Member Jennifer Burke, are now refusing to replace these illegal barriers, citing potential problems with “erosion” and “release of toxic materials.” (The park is situated on a former landfill site).

This ignores the fact that the site has other open entrances and that official research proves that barriers don’t prevent access by illegal motor bikes / ebikes, only more legitimate law-abiding users, including those with disabilities.

The truth about illegal barriers

Unfortunately the council have not made any public announcements about their plans for the park. The Parks department has failed to provide promised updates to C=CC, despite our regular chasers. It also appears that the respective Cabinet members responsible for Parks and Transport are not in agreement about what should happen to the barriers.

All the while, the situation persists where we have illegal barriers which prevent many people from using the Ely Trail on cycles and other adaptive means of transport.

BEFORE: Illegal barriers on the Ely Trail at Grangemoor Park (Penarth Road entrance)

A call to action for Cardiff Council

Users of the Ely Trail have been waiting over three years for this issue to be resolved. We urge the council to act now and stop hiding behind excuses which run contrary to all the evidence:

  • The illegal barriers do not reduce anti-social behaviour
  • Replacing the barriers with compliant structures will increase lawful, legitimate use of the park for Active Travel, thus providing an element of policing and reducing the potential for anti-social behaviour
  • There is no published evidence that “toxic materials” will be released if the barriers are removed

We asked Cardiff Council for comment and have received this joint response from councillors Dan De’ath and Jen Burke (Cabinet members responsible for Transport and Parks respectively):

We can confirm that consultation with the Local Members regarding the removal of these barriers is near complete and Officers hope to progress their removal shortly.

The removal is under the responsibility of Transport, working alongside the University of Westminster, and is being carried out with the understanding that Parks Services will review the collated data from the university, Police and the Council’s Community Safety team to assess any effects on the parks’ ecology and any crime & anti-social behaviour. Should any negative impacts be observed during this period, Transport will reinstall the barriers. 

So whilst it is good to see that the removal of the barriers is now under consideration again, we won’t be putting out the bunting until we see those barriers gone, once and for all.

We look forward to the barriers being removed very soon. We also hope that the council will monitor the POSITIVE impacts of their removal, as well as any negatives. Re-installing the barriers without measuring the positive impact of making the park more accessible would be a blinkered solution, not to mention petty and vindictive. It would also mean that the council are willing to waste public money installing new barriers which do not comply with Active Travel Design Guidelines. This makes a mockery of the principles of the Active Travel Act which the council is supposed adhere to.

Rest assured we will continue to hold the council to account on this issue, and will keep you updated on developments.